Go to the "Select An Icon" screen and select the following icons in order: Monkey, Cat, Koala, Rabbit.
While the host, Ayden Frost, climbs up to the stage and the camera pans the four contestants, remember the places you and the other three characters are standing from left to right.
If your character's standing to the far right on the fourth row, then you're in fourth place. If you are on the first row, your character's in third. If you're on the second row on the left after the third-placer, you're in second; and the third row gives you the much-coveted first place.